
This piece seeks to explore History in an attempt to find an answer to the question: is it possible, in a time of tragedy, war, and destruction, to recover an ethical dimension of humanity?
In Europe, during the Nazi regime, there lived two women who shared the same first name, Ilse. They are remembered here because they embodied two opposite sentiments: the first became a symbol of love, the second of Nazi hatred.
As we shall see, the fact that they shared the same name is completely irrelevant; indeed, as Shakespeare has the protagonist of the tragedy Romeo and Juliet ask: “What’s in a name?”
The first Ilse was Ilse Weber. Born in what is now the Czech Republic in 1903, she was a German-speaking Jew who died on October 6, 1944, in the Auschwitz (Oświęcim) concentration camp. From a very young age, she wrote poems and fairy tales for children. By 1930, she had already published three books of fairy tales and had become a skilled musician, playing the guitar, lute, and balalaika.
At that time, Czechoslovakia was a small island of democracy in Europe, surrounded by the advancing madness of Nazism. Unfortunately, in 1939 the Nazis invaded Poland, and Ilse and her husband sent their eldest son, Hanus, to England to save his life.
Ilse continued to write even after she was imprisoned in the Theresienstadt (Terezín) concentration camp. There she wrote a poem about the “Sheep of Lidice,” a Czech town where a massacre of civilians had taken place, including many children. Only the sheep had survived and had been brought to Terezín. The SS were furious about this poem.
Later, the family was sent to Auschwitz: first her husband, who died shortly afterwards, and then Ilse herself, together with her young son Tomas, who had been named in honour of a Czech hero, as Ilse was also a deeply patriotic woman.
She voluntarily joined a group of fifteen children so that she would not abandon them. She went with them, and with her little Tomas, to their deaths in the gas chamber. She was advised to read and sing to the children as they sat in a circle around her, so that they could die quickly by inhaling the gas, avoiding the panic that would have resulted from people collapsing on top of one another and being crushed.
And that is what she did.
Ilse Weber was not only a poet, an educator, and a mother, she was a heroine.
In this way, she bore witness to love.
The other Ilse was known as Ilse Koch. Born Ilse Köhler, she was the wife of Karl Otto Koch, commander of the Buchenwald concentration camp. She was born in Dresden in 1906 and died in Germany on September 1, 1967. She had four children.
The daughter of farmers, she was described as cheerful and courteous. At the age of fifteen, she went to work in a factory, and later became a librarian. Eventually, she began associating with Nazi officers and soldiers.
She became known as “the Bitch of Buchenwald,” “the Whore of Buchenwald,” and “the Beast of Buchenwald” because, after marrying Koch in 1939, she became a senior supervisor at Buchenwald in 1941, where she exercised cruel sadism and subjected prisoners to torture.
When she passed by, deliberately dressed provocatively, if she disliked the way one of the prisoners looked at her, she would order the soldiers to kill him. In her apartment, she kept as trophies the tattooed skins of Russian prisoners, and these were also used to make lampshades for the unfortunate female prisoners in the camp. She also collected the skulls of prisoners as trophies, known as “tsantsas,” which were reduced in size. She also kept human organs taken from prisoners.
This was only part of the sadism and torture.
In 1944, she was arrested and imprisoned in Weimar. In 1945, the United States arrested her again, and in 1947 she was sentenced to life imprisonment, later commuted to four years by General Lucius Clay. After her release, following protests from Germans, she was imprisoned again and sentenced to life imprisonment.
She had another child by a prisoner, apparently attempting in this way to escape detention. Finally, she hanged herself with bedsheets in her cell.
Every day, we must choose which of the two Ilses we want to be: we must choose the path of love rather than that of hatred.
Living in our comfort zone, taking the middle way, is no longer possible. We must choose and bear witness to love, learning from History.
And so, the answer to the initial question is:
Yes. We still have a possibility.
Isabella Sordi
0 Comments